---
title: "The Choice of the Web Framework"
author: "winzenghua"
date: "2006-09-14T21:32:00Z"
tags: []
slug: "the-choice-of-the-web-framework"
draft: false
lastmod: "2006-09-14T21:32:00Z"
id: 992519
url: "https://java4gis.iteye.com/blog/992519"
---

The Choice of the Web Framework  
Aaron Yuan/2005.12.26

0\. Preface  
Now, the web frameworks bloom in every aspects\[1]. This is can be a good thing, but on the other hand, this also make people confused on choosing the correct one to be based on for their application. So how to do the choice? This article tries to give some useful hints.

1\. Category  
We can classify all the the framework as the browser-centric and [java](http://java.sun.com)-centric. Of course, we will build the business layer and database layer using [java](http://java.sun.com), such as spring and hibernate or EJB3. The key point lay on the presentation layer. Now we have many choice, the most common is :Struts(Action), JSP(JSF), Tapestry, Applet, WingS(webonswing,etc.), webstart. We can draw a line from [java](http://java.sun.com)-centric to browser-centric,  
and every framework should be one position.

JWS(Xito,JDNC,JDIC) Applet WingS(webonswing) wicket JSF(spring MVC,Struts), Tapestry  
[java](http://java.sun.com)-----------------------------&gt;-----------------------&gt;----------------------&gt;------------Broswer

Note: Broswer-centric mean the most presentation job is fulfilled by XML/HTML. And this is the mainstream of the world now.

2\. Compare  
Here is a compare matrix which I come across on the net. Sorry I just can not figure out the specific location.

Factors Applet XML/HTML based JWS

User Interface moderate-sophicated simple-moderate moderate-sophicated  
Offline Support No No Yes  
UI Response Network Independent Network dependent Network Independent  
Interactivity Broswer Limited Broswer/Make-up limited Open  
First Use Response Minutes Seconds Minutes  
Subsequent use response Minutes Seconds Seconds  
Bandwidth Usage Variable Fixed Flexible  
Lightweight client support Limited Open Limited

From the matrix above, we can see many advantes the JWS plan over the others. So why people sitll insist on developing the web service based on the XML/HTML? We can see that that's only one reason: make the user the most convenient. For they do not need to install the [java](http://java.sun.com) SDK or waiting for a while before they start an application caused by the limit of bandwidth. And from these analysis, we also can understand why AJAX(Asynchronous JavaScript And XML) will populate today. Javascirpt is ugly from my  
view although some guys will laught at me for that. I love the pure [java](http://java.sun.com) system. It can be rapidly development and if the architecture is elegant enough, the maintance can be a kind of joy. We can imagine we can develop the same system like what we have, just get rid of so much jsp, xml, html ,css....

3\. Thinking  
Html and Browser is made to present the static the text and the Http protocol is also sessionless. So we will make overhead use of it if we just wanna build the application based on it. Why not shift to [java](http://java.sun.com) platform? I just can not fiugred out. Ruby on Rails? Asp.Net? LAMP? maybe... I just think if the [java](http://java.sun.com) community is more unify...maybe the world will be better.....

In my opition, with the bandwidth growing, the downloading will not a burden, so my choice will be: RIA. On how to do with it, there are  
FLEX  
XUL(Lazlo)  
Swing  
AJAX  
I need write the action script for FlEX or javascipt for AJAX, I do not like that style. As for Lazlo, I still need do that job. I choose Swing. But there are sitll two methods,to use swing: on the server or on the cilent. The reprents of the former is:  
Echo(Echo2)  
WingS  
SwingWeb  
WebOnSwing  
This type solution is cool, but not so applicable. Basicly, They all wrap the servelet using all kinds of method. So when the http requests arrive, the response will generate the html to form the swing-like web. this will comsume a lot of time and brandwidth.  
The reprents of the latter is so many, so only superstar will be choosed here:  
SwiXML(SwiNG,SwiAT)  
CookSwing(CookXML)  
JDNC(JDIC SwingX)

I still choose JWS, but with a little XUL to do the form designer like cookSwing or Thinlet project.

another concern: If we give up the based j2ee server or even webserver(at now, we still use it). Where is the socket? Because the client side have been located in the romote client machine, not like jsp like file (which located in the server), so how to fulfil the basci communication? HTTP? socket? RPC? RPC in fact in based on the socket. While HTTP will still be used. According to the spring spec, it can support the following  
4 choice:

Remote Method Invocation (RMI). Through the use of the RmiProxyFactoryBean and the RmiServiceExporter Spring supports both traditional RMI (with [java](http://java.sun.com).rmi.Remote interfaces and [java](http://java.sun.com).rmi.RemoteException) and transparent remoting via RMI invokers (with any [java](http://java.sun.com) interface).

Spring's HTTP invoker. Spring provides a special remoting strategy which allows for [java](http://java.sun.com) serialization via HTTP, supporting any [java](http://java.sun.com) interface (just like the RMI invoker). The corresponding support classes are HttpInvokerProxyFactoryBean and HttpInvokerServiceExporter.

Hessian. By using the HessianProxyFactoryBean and the HessianServiceExporter you can transparently expose your services using the lightweight binary HTTP-based protocol provided by Caucho.

Burlap. Burlap is Caucho's XML-based alternative for Hessian. Spring provides support classes such as BurlapProxyFactoryBean and BurlapServiceExporter.

JAX RPC. Spring provides remoting support for Web Services via JAX-RPC.

JMS (TODO).

if they have not so.. i will try one: cookSwing+JWS+spring+hibernate.  
\_\_\_\_\_\_\_\_\_\_\_\_\__  
\[1]: Echo Cocoon Millstone OXF  
Struts SOFIA Tapestry WebWork  
RIFE Spring MVC Canyamo Maverick  
JPublish JATO Folium Jucas  
Verge Niggle Bishop Barracuda  
Action Framework Shocks TeaServlet wingS  
Expresso Bento jStatemachine jZonic  
OpenEmcee Turbine Scope Warfare  
JWAA Jaffa Jacquard Macaw  
Smile MyFaces Chiba JBanana  
Jeenius JWarp Genie Melati  
Dovetail Cameleon JFormular Xoplon  
Japple Helma Dinamica WebOnSwing  
Nacho Cassandra Baritus